Credit Guides
Carbon credits are worth about $6 a ton in the voluntary market, but the 45Q tax credit pays $85. See how carbon credits work, prices and who buys them.
Author -
Paulestini Francois
Published -
READ TIME
A ton of carbon dioxide kept out of the air can sell for about $6 as a voluntary carbon credit. The same ton, captured and stored underground, can earn $85 as a federal tax credit. Here's what carbon credits are, how they work, how the voluntary and compliance markets differ, what a carbon credit is worth in 2026 and why tax credits often pay far more.
QUICK ANSWER
A carbon credit represents one metric ton of CO2e that a project avoided or removed. Projects are verified, registered and sold to companies, which retire the credits to offset emissions. A broad index of voluntary credits closed at about $6.30 a ton in September 2026, while the 45Q tax credit pays $85 per ton of stored CO2.
KEY FACTS
What is one carbon credit equal to? One metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) avoided or removed.
How much is a carbon credit worth? A broad voluntary index (AlliedOffsets AO500) closed at $6.30 a ton on September 18, 2026.
What did California carbon allowances sell for? $32.48 each at the August 2026 cap-and-invest auction, above a $27.94 floor.
What is the RGGI carbon price? $37.65 per allowance at the September 2026 auction, up from $19.63 in June 2025.
What is the voluntary carbon market? A largely unregulated market where companies choose to buy credits to meet their own climate goals.
How much is the 45Q tax credit per ton? $85 for stored point-source CO2 and $180 for direct air capture in 2026, with prevailing wage met.
Is 45Q an investment tax credit (ITC) or production tax credit (PTC)? It works like a PTC: it's paid per ton captured each year for 12 years, not on the cost of equipment.
What are carbon credits?
A carbon credit is a tradable certificate representing one metric ton of carbon dioxide, or its equivalent in other greenhouse gases (CO2e), that a project kept out of the air or removed from it. Companies buy carbon credits to offset emissions they can't yet cut, then retire them so they can't be resold.
Credits come from projects like protecting or planting forests, capturing landfill methane, distributing efficient cookstoves or pulling CO2 directly from the air. Each project is measured, checked by an independent auditor and registered, and the registry issues one credit for each ton. When a buyer claims the reduction, the credit is retired in the registry so no one else can count it.
Carbon credits are not the same as clean energy tax credits. One is a market product priced by buyers and sellers. The other is a dollar-for-dollar cut in federal income tax set by Congress, which is why a ton of stored carbon can be worth far more as a tax credit than as a carbon credit.
How do carbon credits work?
Carbon credits work in five steps: a project cuts or removes emissions, the reduction is measured against a baseline, an independent verifier checks it, a registry issues one credit per ton of CO2e, and a buyer retires the credit to claim the offset. The buyer pays the project for each ton.

The baseline is the hardest part. A project has to show its reduction is "additional," meaning it wouldn't have happened without credit revenue, and "permanent," meaning the carbon won't come back out. Forest credits, for example, can be reversed by wildfire or logging. Those questions are the main reason credit quality and prices vary so much.
To address quality, the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market created the Core Carbon Principles (CCPs), a global benchmark for high-integrity credits. It assesses whole credit programs and methodologies, so buyers can look for a CCP label instead of judging each project alone.
What is the difference between voluntary and compliance carbon markets?
In compliance carbon markets, a government caps emissions and companies must hold allowances for what they emit. In the voluntary carbon market, companies choose to buy credits to meet their own climate goals. Compliance prices are usually much higher because companies are legally required to buy.
The two longest-running U.S. compliance markets are in California and the Northeast. California's cap-and-invest program settled at $32.48 per allowance in its August 2026 auction, above a $27.94 floor. The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI), which covers power plants in Northeast and Mid-Atlantic states, cleared at $37.65 in September 2026, up from $19.63 in June 2025.
The voluntary carbon market, often called the carbon offset market, is mostly unregulated. A U.S. Government Accountability Office report from August 2025 found that "the federal government has had a limited role in voluntary carbon markets," with agencies like the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and Treasury offering only some oversight or guidance.
How much is a carbon credit worth?
Carbon credit prices range from a few dollars a ton to roughly $100 in Europe's compliance market. A broad index of voluntary credits closed at $6.30 a ton in September 2026, while compliance allowances traded around $32 to $38 in the U.S. and about 88 euros in the European Union.
Across the carbon credit market, no single price exists. The $6.30 voluntary benchmark is the AlliedOffsets AO500 index. Within the voluntary market, project type drives price: avoidance credits, like protecting forests that might be cut, usually sell for less than removal credits, like engineered carbon removal, which are scarcer and harder to reverse. The European Union's allowance price was about 88 euros a ton on November 13, 2026, according to Trading Economics.
A broad index of voluntary carbon credits (AlliedOffsets AO500) closed at $6.30 a ton on September 18, 2026. Prices vary widely by project type and quality.
Sources: AlliedOffsets AO500 (Sept 18, 2026); CARB Joint Auction #48 report (Aug 2026); RGGI Auction 73 (Sept 2026, per short ton); Trading Economics EU Carbon Permits (Nov 13, 2026, euros); 26 U.S.C. 45Q (2026 rates with prevailing wage). Tax credit values are not market prices.
Why can a ton of carbon be worth $85 as a tax credit?
Because Congress set it. The 45Q tax credit pays $85 per metric ton of CO2 captured at an industrial or power plant and stored or used, and $180 per ton for direct air capture, when prevailing wage and apprenticeship rules are met. That's more than 13 times the voluntary index price.

Under 26 U.S.C. 45Q, the base rate is $17 per ton, or $36 for direct air capture, and it's multiplied by five for projects that meet labor rules. It's paid for 12 years after the capture equipment is placed in service, construction must begin before 2033, and since the 2025 tax law storage, utilization and enhanced oil recovery earn the same rate. Our 45Q tax credit guide covers the full rules.
The bigger difference is who pays. A carbon credit needs a voluntary buyer willing to pay for an offset. A 45Q credit reduces federal tax, and projects without enough tax liability can sell it to corporations for cash under Section 6418, usually at a discount of only a few cents per dollar of credit. That makes 45Q revenue far more predictable for project finance.
Storing 250,000 metric tons a year from an industrial or power plant earns $85 per ton under 45Q, about $255.0M over 12 years, or $237.2M in cash if you sell the credits at 93 cents. The same tons sold as voluntary carbon credits at $6.30 would bring about $18.9M. A voluntary credit would need to sell for about $79 a ton to match.
Illustrative. 45Q rates are for 2026 and adjust for inflation after 2026. Tons must be measured and verified under IRS rules. Whether the same tons can also be sold as voluntary carbon credits depends on the registry's double-claiming rules and your buyer contracts. Not tax, legal or investment advice.
How do carbon credits compare with clean energy tax credits?
Carbon credits are private, variable and priced per ton, while clean energy tax credits are federal, fixed by law and priced per ton, kilowatt-hour or dollar invested. Tax credits are also transferable for cash, so they're easier to finance. Carbon credits suit projects that don't qualify for tax credits.
Besides 45Q, clean energy projects can earn the investment tax credit (ITC) or production tax credit (PTC) for solar, wind, storage and other technologies (see our ITC vs. PTC guide), plus the 45V credit for clean hydrogen and the 45Z credit for clean fuels. Renewable energy certificates are a third, separate product that tracks clean electricity, covered in our guide to SRECs. For how credit sales work, see our guide to transferable tax credits.
Can a project earn both carbon credits and tax credits?
Sometimes, but it depends on the registry's rules on double claiming and on what buyers will accept. Section 45Q itself doesn't mention voluntary carbon credits, but selling the same stored ton twice can raise integrity questions. Get registry and tax advice before stacking them.
In practice, carbon capture developers usually build their financing around 45Q because the rate is fixed and the credit can be sold. Some also sell carbon removal credits to corporate buyers who want removals for net-zero goals. If you plan to do both, write the claiming rules into your offtake contracts and disclose the tax credit to the registry and the buyer.
Who buys carbon credits, and are they worth it?
Carbon credits are bought by companies with net-zero goals, airlines, fuel suppliers, financial traders and, in compliance markets, regulated emitters. They're worth it for a buyer when the credits are high quality and come after real emission cuts, not instead of them.

The voluntary carbon market has been through a rough few years, as critics argued that some forest credits overstated their impact, pushing many buyers toward higher-quality, verified projects. For a business, the safest approach is to cut its own emissions first, buy credits with a recognized quality label and make claims it can back up.
For project owners, the question is usually which revenue is bigger and more reliable. Use the calculator above to compare 45Q with voluntary credits for your own tons. If your project qualifies for a federal tax credit, that's often the larger and steadier source of cash.
Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
Can individuals buy carbon credits?
Yes. Individuals can buy voluntary carbon credits through retailers and offset platforms. Look for credits certified by a recognized standard and retired in a public registry on your behalf, so they can't be resold.
Are carbon credits a scam?
How do farmers earn carbon credits?
Are carbon credits taxable income?
Can Cenet Capital help me sell carbon credits?
Capturing carbon?
Cenet Capital helps carbon capture and clean energy developers value federal tax credits like 45Q and sell them to corporate buyers for cash, often a steadier source of revenue than voluntary carbon credits. Share your project, tons and timeline, and we'll show you what your credits could bring in.
More Insights






